DHS ends temporary protected status for Afghan refugees, drawing criticism


Summary

TPS for Afghans ending

The Department of Homeland Security will end Temporary Protected Status for Afghan refugees, potentially forcing over 9,000 people to return to Afghanistan.

Advocates condemn DHS

DHS cited improved conditions and national security concerns, while critics, including AfghanEvac, condemned the move as politically motivated and dangerous.

UN raises humanitarian concerns

The UN reports rising deportations and is seeking $75 billion in aid amid worsening conditions in Afghanistan.


Summary

TPS for Afghans ending

The Department of Homeland Security will end Temporary Protected Status for Afghan refugees, potentially forcing over 9,000 people to return to Afghanistan.

Advocates condemn DHS

DHS cited improved conditions and national security concerns, while critics, including AfghanEvac, condemned the move as politically motivated and dangerous.

UN raises humanitarian concerns

The UN reports rising deportations and is seeking $75 billion in aid amid worsening conditions in Afghanistan.


Full story

The Department of Homeland Security is removing Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Afghan refugees, Secretary Kristi Noem announced Monday. The decision could force more than 9,000 Afghan nationals – including women, children and Afghans who assisted the U.S. military during its years-long occupation – to return to their homeland under Taliban rule, Politico reports.

DHS cites improvements in Afghanistan

Secretary Noem said DHS has reviewed the situation in Afghanistan and concluded that it has improved enough, specifically in terms of security and the economy, for Afghans to return home safely.

Noem also said some TPS holders may pose risks.

“Additionally, the termination furthers the national interest as DHS records indicate that there are recipients who have been under investigation for fraud and threatening our public safety and national security,” Noem said. “Reviewing TPS designations is a key part of restoring integrity in our immigration system.” 

In a press release, DHS announced that Temporary Protected Status for Afghans will expire on May 20 and that the termination will take effect on July 12.

Unbiased. Straight Facts.TM

As of September 2024, more than 9,000 people from Afghanistan were covered by temporary protected status.

Background on Afghan TPS and humanitarian parole

The Taliban retook control of Afghanistan in 2021 as the U.S. military withdrew after two decades. The country quickly became unstable and dangerous, prompting President Biden to grant TPS to Afghans because it was not safe for them to return home.

During the 2021 crisis, American forces evacuated thousands of Afghans, many of whom were brought to the United States under “humanitarian parole.” This temporary legal status allows individuals to enter the country and stay for urgent reasons but does not lead to permanent residency.

Advocacy group calls DHS decision ‘unconscionable’

#AfghanEvac, an organization that helps Afghans resettle in the United States, criticized the move.

In a post on X, Shawn VanDiver, the organization’s president, called DHS’s move “unconscionable.”

“The decision to terminate TPS for Afghanistan is not rooted in reality—it’s rooted in politics,” VanDiver said. “Afghanistan remains under the control of the Taliban. There is no functioning asylum system. There are still assassinations, arbitrary arrests, and ongoing human rights abuses, especially against women and ethnic minorities.”

“What the administration has done today is betray people who risked their lives for America, built lives here, and believed in our promises,” VanDiver added.

UN: Millions of Afghans deported or returning

According to a new report by the United Nations Refugee Agency, more than 3.4 million Afghans have either returned to Afghanistan or been deported from Iran and Pakistan since 2023.

More than 250,000 Afghans returned in April alone.

“The large-scale returns are putting even greater pressure on already stretched humanitarian resources and worsening the plight of millions struggling to survive,” the UN said in the report.

The agency says it is seeking $75 billion to assist Afghans who are being deported back to their home country or who are voluntarily returning home.

Bast Bramhall (Video Editor) contributed to this report.
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Why this story matters

The decision by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to revoke Temporary Protected Status for Afghans could lead to thousands of Afghan nationals, including those who aided the U.S. military, facing deportation to a country still under Taliban rule, raising humanitarian, legal, and security concerns.

Immigration policy

Changes to Temporary Protected Status directly affect the lives and legal status of thousands of Afghans in the United States, highlighting the shifting priorities and approach of U.S. immigration policy.

Humanitarian impact

According to both advocacy groups and the United Nations, ending protected status for Afghans could expose many to danger and hardship upon return to Afghanistan, raising significant ethical and humanitarian considerations.

National security and integrity

According to Secretary Kristi Noem and DHS statements, reviews and investigations into fraud and public safety threats have been cited as reasons for the decision, illustrating ongoing debates over the balance between national security and immigration protections.

Get the big picture

Synthesized coverage insights across 21 media outlets

Context corner

The Temporary Protected Status program allows immigrants from designated countries to remain in the U.S. if their home countries are unsafe due to conflict, disasters, or other extraordinary conditions. Afghanistan received this designation after the Taliban’s return to power in 2021, which created conditions labeled as unsafe for return, particularly for certain vulnerable groups like former U.S. allies.

Oppo research

Opponents of the TPS termination, including advocacy groups and some former military officials, cite ongoing Taliban persecution and human rights abuses in Afghanistan. Legal challenges focus on claims that proper administrative procedures weren’t followed. Critics argue the policy disregards ongoing dangers, especially for those who assisted U.S. forces or belong to persecuted minorities.

Underreported

Little coverage is given to specific alternative pathways for legal status or protection for Afghans losing TPS, such as potential eligibility for asylum, Special Immigrant Visas, or humanitarian parole. Also, the long-term social and economic contributions of Afghan TPS recipients to U.S. communities are largely unexamined across articles.

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the termination of Temporary Protected Status for Afghans as a harmful political betrayal, emphasizing ongoing Taliban human rights abuses and portraying the policy reversal as a removal of vital "protections" from vulnerable individuals. They employ emotionally charged language like "betray" to underscore moral outrage.
  • Media outlets in the center focus on alleged fraud and administrative abuses, de-emphasizing human rights issues highlighted by the left and downplaying legal challenges prominent on the right.
  • Media outlets on the right highlight procedural correctness and national security, framing the decision as restoring immigration system "integrity" and criticizing prior policies as “amnesty” resting on flawed vetting, using terms like “terrorism flags” to evoke security fears.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

35 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • The Trump administration announced the end of temporary protected status for Afghans, stating that conditions in Afghanistan have improved.
  • The Trump administration is ending legal protections for Afghans from deportation due to an allegedly improved security situation in Afghanistan, as stated by Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem.
  • Kristi Noem stated, "Afghanistan has had an improved security situation, and its stabilizing economy no longer prevents them from returning to their home country."
  • According to the non-profit organization AfghanEvac, about 11,000 Afghans currently benefit from the temporary protected status in the U.S.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • On May 12, 2025, the Trump administration announced that it will terminate the Temporary Protected Status designation for Afghan nationals residing in the United States, with the change taking effect on July 12.
  • This decision follows the Biden administration's 2021–2023 resettlement of tens of thousands of Afghans under TPS due to instability, while acknowledging varied views on security conditions in Afghanistan.
  • Authorities have reported cases of fraud and some unvetted Afghans linked to threats against U.S. security, including a man accused of planning a terrorist attack and individuals involved with IEDs targeting troops.
  • Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem explained that ending TPS aligns with national priorities, as Department of Homeland Security data show some beneficiaries are suspected of fraud and pose risks to public safety and national security.
  • The program’s end reflects a review concluding Afghanistan’s improving conditions no longer meet TPS requirements, signaling a shift toward restoring immigration system integrity and encouraging return.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • The Department of Homeland Security revoked Temporary Protected Status for Afghan nationals, stating that Afghanistan no longer meets TPS criteria due to improved conditions.
  • DHS Secretary Kristi Noem declared that Afghanistan's security and economy have stabilized, allowing for Afghan nationals to return home safely.
  • The TPS termination becomes effective on July 12, 2025, with the current status expiring on May 20, 2025, according to DHS.
  • A lawsuit was filed by CASA Inc. Against the DHS, claiming the termination process was improper, as TPS designations require specific procedural steps before ending.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™